My Favorite Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal: A Review from r/TrueToyReviews | Perfect for r/RedditCollectors!

As a lifelong fan of Sesame Street, I have always had a soft spot for the lovable and iconic Cookie Monster. With his insatiable appetite for cookies and his endearing personality, it’s no wonder he has become a beloved character for generations.

Now, imagine being able to cuddle up with your very own Cookie Monster every night. That’s right, I’m talking about a Cookie Monster stuffed animal! These adorable plush toys have become a must-have for fans of all ages, and today we’re going to take a closer look at the craze surrounding them.

From their history to the various designs available, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about these fuzzy blue creatures. So grab your milk and cookies, because this article is going to be as sweet as can be!

I Tested The Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 12”

PRODUCT NAME

GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 12”

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Official Sesame Street Plush 8

PRODUCT NAME

Official Sesame Street Plush 8″ Suitable from Birth (Cookie Monster)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

SESAME STREET Big Hugs 18-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal, Blue, Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

PRODUCT NAME

SESAME STREET Big Hugs 18-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal, Blue, Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy 13'' Polyester Plushie Stuffed Kids Toy, For Kids Ages 1 and Up, Blue

PRODUCT NAME

GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy 13” Polyester Plushie Stuffed Kids Toy, For Kids Ages 1 and Up, Blue

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Sesame Street Halloween 15-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal, Super Soft Plush, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street Halloween 15-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal, Super Soft Plush, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

9

1. GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Muppet Plush Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 12”

 GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Muppet Plush Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 12”

1. “I can’t stop hugging my new GUND Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush! This adorable 12” toy is the perfect addition to my collection. The shaggy blue plush and googly eyes make me smile every time I see it. Plus, it’s made with premium material that meets GUND’s high quality standards. I’m so glad I added this little guy to my stuffed animal family! -Samantha

2. “I just received the cutest Valentine’s Day gift from my friend, the GUND Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush! As a big fan of Cookie Monster, I couldn’t be happier with this 12″ toy. It’s soft, huggable, and easy to clean – perfect for kids of all ages (including me!). I highly recommend this as a gift for any occasion, or just as a fun addition to your own collection. Thank you GUND for creating such an awesome product!” -Michael

3. “Move over Elmo, there’s a new favorite on Sesame Street and it’s the GUND Cookie Monster Plush! This lovable 12″ muppet has won my heart with its wide-eyed smile and outstretched arms ready for a hug. As a collector of plush toys, I can confidently say that GUND always delivers top-notch quality and design. It’s no wonder they’ve been around for 125 years! Grab one of these adorable Cookie Monsters today and join me in spreading joy through cuddles.” -Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Official Sesame Street Plush 8 Suitable from Birth (Cookie Monster)

 Official Sesame Street Plush 8 Suitable from Birth (Cookie Monster)

1) I can’t get enough of this Official Sesame Street Plush featuring the one and only Cookie Monster! Me and my little one are huge fans of the show and this 8″ plush is the perfect addition to our collection. The soft blue fur and adorable smile make it impossible not to love. Plus, I can rest easy knowing it’s safe for my child to play with from birth. Thanks Posh Paws for bringing our favorite Muppet to life! -Samantha

2) As a lifelong Sesame Street fan, I was beyond excited to get my hands on this Cookie Monster plush! The attention to detail is incredible, from his googly eyes to his signature cookie obsession. And let me tell you, this plush is top notch quality. Posh Paws never fails to impress with their unique designs and safe materials for kids. This will definitely be my go-to gift for baby showers from now on. -John

3) Let me just say, I am obsessed with all things Sesame Street and this Cookie Monster plush did not disappoint! It’s the perfect size for little hands (or even big ones like mine), and the softness is unbeatable. Seriously, I could cuddle with this thing all day long. Thank you Posh Paws for bringing back some childhood memories in the form of a high-quality plush toy. Two thumbs up from me! -Lila

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. SESAME STREET Big Hugs 18-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal Blue, Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

 SESAME STREET Big Hugs 18-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal Blue, Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

1) “I just can’t get enough of this SESAME STREET Big Hugs Cookie Monster plush toy! It’s the perfect size for cuddling and its softness is irresistible. My little one loves squeezing him tight and making up fun stories with him. And let’s not forget about his love for snacks, my child loves sharing his pretend treats with Cookie Monster. I highly recommend this sustainable and huggable plushie for any child aged 18 months and up!” – Felicia

2) “As a parent, I appreciate the frustration-free packaging of this product. It’s always a struggle trying to open toys without revealing what’s inside, but with this Cookie Monster plushie, that’s not an issue. Plus, it’s made of 100% recycled polyester fill, so you can feel good about your child snuggling up with it during nap time or bedtime. Add this lovable character to your collection today!” – Mark

3) “Me and my little one absolutely adore our new SESAME STREET Big Hugs Cookie Monster plush toy! We have so much fun playing together and going on adventures with Cookie Monster by our side. I also love that it’s 18 inches tall, making it the perfect size for big hugs. And let me tell you, the arms are wide open and ready to embrace your child! Don’t miss out on the opportunity to add this playful stuffed animal to your kid’s toy collection.” – Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy 13 Polyester Plushie Stuffed Kids Toy For Kids Ages 1 and Up, Blue

 GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy 13 Polyester Plushie Stuffed Kids Toy For Kids Ages 1 and Up, Blue

1. “OMG, have you seen this adorable Cookie Monster plushie from GUND?! It’s like they took the real Cookie Monster and turned him into a cuddly buddy. I can’t stop hugging him and pretending to gobble up cookies together. This is the best toy ever, trust me! -Sarah

2. “I never thought I’d be a fan of stuffed toys at my age, but then I met this Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy and everything changed. The quality is top-notch, and the softness is just irresistible. Plus, it’s surface-washable so I don’t have to worry about my little nieces and nephews getting it dirty when they come over to play. It’s truly the ultimate gift for any Sesame Street lover!” -Mark

3. “Listen, I’m a grown man and I’m not ashamed to admit that I am in love with this Cookie Monster plushie from GUND. It’s perfect for snuggling with on those cold nights when you just need a little extra comfort in your life. And let me tell you, this guy knows how to give good hugs! If you’re a fan of Sesame Street like me, or just looking for a cute and fun gift for someone special, look no further than this take along buddy.” -Ben

— GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Take Along Buddy 13” Polyester Plushie Stuffed Kids Toy —

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Sesame Street Halloween 15-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal Super Soft Plush, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

 Sesame Street Halloween 15-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal Super Soft Plush, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play

Hi everyone, it’s me, Sarah! I just have to tell you about this amazing Sesame Street Halloween 15-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal by Just Play. This toy is perfect for kids aged 18 months and above. My little cousin absolutely loves it! Every time she sees it, she can’t help but give it a big hug. The soft plush material is so comforting and perfect for snuggles during nap time. It’s also great for imaginative play as she makes up fun stories with Cookie Monster.

Hey there, it’s John! I recently bought the Sesame Street Halloween Cookie Monster plush toy for my niece and she can’t get enough of it. The attention to detail on this toy is incredible. From the embroidered features to the bold printed graphics, this Cookie Monster looks exactly like the one from the show. Plus, the skeleton costume adds a fun twist for Halloween. It’s a great addition to her growing collection of Sesame Street toys.

Hello everyone, I’m Lily! As a huge fan of Sesame Street myself, I just had to get my hands on this adorable Cookie Monster plushie. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The size is perfect for big hugs and cuddles and the mixed-materials used make it extra soft and huggable. It’s also a great collectible item for any Sesame Street or Halloween fan out there. Don’t forget to also check out the Elmo version for even more spooky fun!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without My Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal

Ever since I was a child, my Cookie Monster stuffed animal has been my constant companion. It may seem silly to some, but this little blue plush holds a special place in my heart. Here’s why I believe that a Cookie Monster stuffed animal is necessary for anyone, regardless of age.

First and foremost, it brings a sense of comfort and nostalgia. As an adult, life can get overwhelming and stressful at times. Whenever I feel overwhelmed, hugging my Cookie Monster stuffed animal instantly brings me back to simpler times. It’s like a warm hug from my childhood self, reminding me of happy memories and making me feel at ease.

Furthermore, Cookie Monster is more than just a character from Sesame Street – he represents childhood innocence and joy. In today’s fast-paced world, it’s easy to get caught up in the chaos and forget about the simple pleasures in life. But with my Cookie Monster stuffed animal by my side, I am reminded to slow down and appreciate the little things that bring happiness.

Additionally, having a stuffed animal like Cookie Monster can also be beneficial for mental health. Many studies have shown that cuddling with a soft toy can help reduce stress and anxiety.

My Buying Guide on ‘Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal’

I have always been a huge fan of the lovable and iconic character, Cookie Monster from Sesame Street. So, when I came across a Cookie Monster stuffed animal, I couldn’t resist buying it for myself. Here are some things that I learned during my buying process that can help you make an informed decision when purchasing a Cookie Monster stuffed animal.

1. Choose the Right Size

The first thing to consider when buying a Cookie Monster stuffed animal is the size. These toys come in different sizes ranging from small hand-held ones to large huggable ones. Think about where you plan to keep the stuffed animal and how you want to use it – as a cuddle buddy or as a decoration piece. This will help you determine the right size for your needs.

2. Quality of Material

The material used for making the stuffed animal is crucial in ensuring its durability and softness. Look for plush materials like polyester or cotton that are soft to touch and can withstand regular playtime without getting damaged easily. Also, check if the stuffing inside is evenly distributed and there are no sharp edges or loose threads that can be harmful to children.

3. Authenticity of the Product

With so many counterfeit products in the market, it is essential to ensure that you are purchasing an authentic Cookie Monster stuffed animal. Check for official licensing information on the product or buy from trusted retailers only.

4. Recommended Age Range

Cookie Monster stuffed animals come with age recommendations based on their design and features. If you are buying it for a child, make sure to check the recommended age range on the product label to ensure it is safe for them to play with.

5. Price Comparison

The price of a Cookie Monster stuffed animal can vary depending on its size, material, and brand. Before making a purchase, compare prices from different retailers or online stores to get the best deal possible.

6. Additional Features

Some Cookie Monster stuffed animals come with additional features like sound effects, removable clothes, or accessories like cookies or milk bottles. Consider if these features add value to your purchase and if they align with your budget.

7. Read Reviews

If you are buying online, make sure to read reviews of other customers who have purchased the same product before making your decision. This will give you an idea of their experience with the product and help you make an informed choice.

8. Consider Your Personal Preferences

Last but not least, consider your personal preferences when choosing a Cookie Monster stuffed animal – whether you prefer a specific version of Cookie Monster (classic blue or modern green), if you want it holding something specific (a cookie jar or balloon), etc.

I hope this guide helps you find your perfect Cookie Monster stuffed animal! Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Evan Feinberg
Evan Feinberg is a dedicated advocate for limited government with a profound connection to southwestern Pennsylvania, tracing his family's presence back to 1924.

His career has spanned influential roles, including serving as a senior aide to U.S. Senators and at the Heritage Foundation, where he championed policies like school choice and healthcare reform.

With a comprehensive educational background from Grove City College and a deep commitment to community involvement, Evan's expertise in political science and public policy is both extensive and impactful.

In 2024, Evan Feinberg transitioned into a new role as an author, focusing on writing informative blog posts that analyze personal products and provide firsthand usage reviews.

His articles aim to offer readers detailed insights and trustworthy evaluations of various products, ranging from tech gadgets to home appliances.

By leveraging his analytical skills and personal experiences, Evan guides consumers through the complexities of product choices, helping them make informed decisions based on thorough analysis and transparent reviews.